Better Chemistry Through Breathing

Understanding the Hidden Power of Carbon Dioxide: The Paradox of the Waste Gas That Keeps Us Alive

When we think about breathing, most of us focus on oxygen as the star of the show. Yet Dr. Christopher Gilbert's groundbreaking work "Better Chemistry Through Breathing" reveals a surprising truth: carbon dioxide, the waste gas we exhale with every breath, plays an equally vital role in maintaining our health and wellbeing. This seemingly simple molecule holds the key to understanding why so many people experience mysterious symptoms ranging from tingling fingers to panic attacks, all stemming from subtle breathing imbalances they may not even notice.

The story of carbon dioxide in our bodies reads like a carefully choreographed dance. As it travels through our bloodstream on its way to being exhaled, CO2 transforms into carbonic acid, serving as the primary regulator of our blood's pH level. This delicate balance keeps our blood at exactly 7.35 pH, a precision so critical that even small deviations can trigger cascading symptoms throughout the body. When we breathe normally, our bodies maintain about 5% CO2 in arterial blood, creating perfect harmony between production and elimination.

When Breathing Exceeds Our Needs

Hyperventilation, as Gilbert explains, doesn't look like what most people imagine. Forget the dramatic gasping and paper bag scenes from movies. Clinical hyperventilation is simply breathing that exceeds our current metabolic needs, and it can be so subtle that even trained observers might miss it. The real problem isn't that we're breathing too fast, but that we're exhaling more carbon dioxide than our body is producing.

This creates a state called hypocapnia, where CO2 levels drop below normal. The fascinating paradox here is that while people who hyperventilate often feel they can't get enough air, they actually have plenty of oxygen. The sensation of air hunger comes not from oxygen deficiency but from the disruption of the CO2 balance that our bodies depend on for proper function.

Consider what happens during even one minute of deliberate overbreathing. Your hands grow cold and pale as peripheral blood vessels constrict. Tingling sensations spread through your fingers and lips as nerve conduction becomes disrupted. Muscles begin twitching as their contraction thresholds lower. Most dramatically, blood vessels in your brain constrict, reducing cerebral blood flow and affecting everything from vision and hearing to judgment and memory.

The Chronic Overbreather's Dilemma

While acute hyperventilation episodes grab attention during panic attacks or moments of shock, chronic, subtle hyperventilation affects far more people and creates a more complex problem. When someone maintains a pattern of slight overbreathing for weeks or months, their body attempts to compensate. The kidneys begin excreting bicarbonate to restore pH balance, creating what Gilbert calls a "compensated" state.

This compensation comes at a significant cost. The body establishes a new, fragile equilibrium that depends on continued hyperventilation to maintain. These individuals live in a precarious state where any additional stress or change in breathing pattern can trigger severe symptoms. They often report persistent fatigue, muscle pain, difficulty concentrating, and ironically, a constant feeling that they can't get enough air. Their breath-holding time typically drops to less than 20 seconds, compared to the normal 30 to 60 seconds most people can manage comfortably.

The Psychology of Breath

Gilbert's work reveals fascinating connections between our emotional states and breathing patterns. He introduces the concept of "action projection," where our bodies prepare for anticipated physical actions that never materialize. Imagine preparing to confront someone who upset you. Your breathing accelerates as your body readies for action, but modern social constraints mean you likely won't engage in the physical confrontation your primitive systems anticipated. You're left in a state of respiratory alkalosis with nowhere for that preparation to go.

Trauma survivors face particular challenges with breathing regulation. Research by Nixon and Bryant demonstrated that when individuals with Acute Stress Disorder deliberately hyperventilated for just three minutes, they experienced increased trauma-related memories and flashbacks. The physiological state created by overbreathing appears to directly trigger the re-experiencing of traumatic events, creating a vicious cycle where anxiety drives hyperventilation, which then intensifies psychological symptoms.

This bidirectional relationship between breathing and emotion creates what Gilbert calls a "psychosomatic loop." Anxious individuals misinterpret the physical symptoms of hyperventilation as signs of serious illness or impending doom. This interpretation heightens their anxiety, which further disrupts their breathing, amplifying the original symptoms in an escalating spiral.

The Measurement Challenge

Detecting chronic hyperventilation presents unique challenges for healthcare providers. Unlike many medical conditions with clear visual markers, chronic overbreathing often goes unnoticed. The respiratory rate might appear normal, and the breathing pattern may seem unremarkable to casual observation. Clinicians must look for subtle clues: frequent sighing, upper chest breathing, breath-holding patterns, and a constellation of seemingly unrelated symptoms.

The Nijmegen Hyperventilation Questionnaire has emerged as a valuable screening tool, with its 16-item checklist correlating highly with clinical diagnoses. Symptoms range from the obvious respiratory complaints to less intuitive markers like cold hands and feet, bloating, and difficulty swallowing. The diversity of symptoms often leads people on long diagnostic journeys before anyone considers their breathing as the root cause.

For precise measurement, clinicians use capnometry to measure end tidal CO2, the carbon dioxide concentration at the very end of exhalation. This provides real-time feedback about CO2 levels and can reveal patterns invisible to the naked eye. Studies have shown that individuals vary significantly in their response to the same CO2 drop, with some experiencing severe symptoms at levels that barely affect others.

The Cortical Impact

The brain bears the brunt of hyperventilation's effects, particularly the cortex responsible for our higher functions. When CO2 levels drop and cerebral blood vessels constrict, the resulting reduction in blood flow creates a state of mild cerebral hypoxia. This oxygen deprivation manifests as impaired judgment, reduced reaction time, memory difficulties, and visual disturbances.

Research on test anxiety provides a compelling example. Students with high test anxiety show measurably lower CO2 levels and higher respiratory rates during exams. This physiological state directly impairs the cognitive functions needed for optimal performance, creating a self-perpetuating cycle where anxiety about performance leads to breathing changes that ensure poorer performance.

Rethinking Relaxation Breathing

The conventional advice to "take a deep breath" when stressed may actually worsen hyperventilation. Gilbert points out that people often interpret "deep" as meaning large volume, leading them to take massive inhalations that further deplete CO2. This well-intentioned but misguided instruction has probably triggered more hyperventilation episodes than it has prevented.

Better breathing instructions should focus on pace and location rather than volume. "Low and slow" breathing, where the emphasis is on diaphragmatic movement and extended exhalation, allows CO2 to rebuild properly. The key is breathing at a rate that matches metabolic needs, typically around 8 to 10 breaths per minute at rest, with exhalation lasting longer than inhalation.

Exercise and the CO2 Balance

An important distinction Gilbert makes concerns exercise and breathing. Heavy breathing during physical activity isn't hyperventilation because increased muscle activity produces more CO2, which matches the increased respiratory rate. The body maintains its crucial balance even as production and elimination accelerate. This explains why the same breathing rate that would cause symptoms at rest feels perfectly normal during a workout.

The Medical Significance of pH

The consequences of pH imbalance extend far beyond discomfort. Blood pH below 7.0 leads to severe acidosis, causing disorientation, coma, and potentially death. At the other extreme, pH above 7.7 creates dangerous alkalosis with similar life-threatening outcomes. While hyperventilation rarely pushes pH to these extremes, even modest shifts toward alkalinity can significantly impact quality of life.

Medical professionals sometimes use controlled hyperventilation therapeutically, such as reducing brain swelling after head injuries. This calculated use of CO2 depletion demonstrates both the power and the danger of manipulating this fundamental physiological process.

Integration and Healing

Understanding hyperventilation as Gilbert presents it transforms how we approach numerous health complaints. Rather than treating individual symptoms in isolation, recognizing the breathing connection allows for addressing the root cause. Biofeedback training, where individuals learn to monitor and modify their breathing patterns using real time CO2 measurements, has shown remarkable success in breaking the hyperventilation habit.

The path to better breathing isn't about constant vigilance or forced control. Instead, it involves retraining the nervous system to establish healthier automatic patterns. This might include specific exercises, postural adjustments, stress management techniques, and most importantly, awareness of the subtle ways our breathing reflects and influences our emotional state.

Five Key Takeaways

1. Hyperventilation is not about breathing too fast but about exhaling more CO2 than your body produces, and it can be so subtle that neither you nor observers notice it happening.

   
   

2. Carbon dioxide acts as a master regulator in your body, controlling blood pH and blood vessel diameter, making it essential for proper brain function and overall health.

   
   

3. Chronic overbreathing creates a compensated state where your body depends on continued hyperventilation to maintain balance, leaving you vulnerable to severe symptoms from minor stressors.

   
   

4. The bidirectional relationship between breathing and emotion means anxiety can trigger hyperventilation while hyperventilation can trigger anxiety, trauma memories, and panic, creating self perpetuating cycles.

   
   

5. Effective breathing retraining focuses on "low and slow" diaphragmatic breathing with extended exhalation, not the commonly misunderstood advice to "take deep breaths."

Glossary

acidosis: a condition where blood pH falls below normal (less than 7.35), indicating excess acid in the body.

action projection: the body's preparation for anticipated physical action that doesn't materialize, leaving physiological arousal without release.

acute stress disorder: a mental health condition occurring in the first month following a traumatic event.

alkalosis: a condition where blood pH rises above normal (greater than 7.4), indicating excess alkalinity in the body.

capnometry: the measurement of carbon dioxide concentration in exhaled breath, particularly at the end of exhalation.

carbonic acid: a weak acid formed when CO2 dissolves in blood, crucial for maintaining pH balance.

cerebral hypoxia: insufficient oxygen supply to the brain, which can result from vasoconstriction during hyperventilation.

cerebral vasoconstriction: The narrowing of blood vessels in the brain, reducing blood flow and oxygen delivery.

hypocapnia: below normal levels of carbon dioxide in the blood, the defining feature of hyperventilation.

metabolic needs: the body's moment-to-moment requirements for oxygen and removal of CO2 based on current activity level.

Nijmegen Hyperventilation Questionnaire: a validated 16-item screening tool for identifying hyperventilation syndrome.

peripheral nerve conduction: the transmission of signals through nerves in the limbs and extremities.

pH: the measure of acidity or alkalinity in a solution, with normal blood pH at approximately 7.35 to 7.4.

psychosomatic loop: the circular relationship where psychological states affect physical symptoms, which then influence psychological states.

respiratory alkalosis: increased blood alkalinity caused by excessive removal of CO2 through overbreathing.

vascular tone: the degree of constriction in blood vessels that regulates blood flow throughout the body.

vasodilation: the widening of blood vessels, increasing blood flow to tissues.

References

Gilbert, C. (2005). Better chemistry through breathing: The story of carbon dioxide and how it can go wrong. Biofeedback, 33(3), 100-104.

Ley, R., & Yelich, G. (1998). Fractional end-tidal CO2 as an index of the effect of stress on math performance and verbal memory in test-anxious adolescents. Biological Psychology, 49, 83-94.

Nixon, R., & Bryant, R. (2005). Induced arousal and re-experiencing in acute stress disorder. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 19, 587-594.

About the Author

Fred Shaffer earned his PhD in Psychology from Oklahoma State University. He earned BCIA certifications in Biofeedback and HRV Biofeedback. Fred is an Allen Fellow and Professor of Psychology at Truman State University, where has has taught for 50 years. He is a Biological Psychologist who consults and lectures in heart rate variability biofeedback, Physiological Psychology, and Psychopharmacology. Fred helped to edit Evidence-Based Practice in Biofeedback and Neurofeedback (3rd and 4th eds.) and helped to maintain BCIA's certification programs.

Support Our Friends